Visa-fraud scheme: Gov. Phil Murphy’s professional soccer team named in immigration scandal


NEW JERSEY – Sky Blue FC, the professional women’s soccer team that is co-owned by Governor Phil Murphy and his wife Tammy, has been named in court documents pertaining to a visa scandal

While neither Governor Murphy nor his wife are being charged or accused of any wrongdoing, the soccer team is one of seven professional teams that allegedly engaged in a visa program that illegally brought foreign coaches and scouts to the United States

According to the Department of Justice, the center of the investigation and alleged criminal conduct relating to visa fraud stems around the now defunct Global Premier Soccer. 

On February 12th, the DOJ announced that 39-year-old Justin Capell, the former COO of GPS, was being charged, “in connection with a wide-ranging visa fraud conspiracy.”

The purported visa scheme enacted by Capell and, “other GPS executives and employees,” that have yet to be named was said to have transpired between some point in 2016 up until October of 2019. 

In said alleged scheme, the DOJ stated that: 

“Capell conspired with other GPS executives and employees, and with GPS’s outside counsel, to defraud several federal agencies by submitting fraudulent visa petitions in order to secure work visas for hundreds of GPS employees.”

In the simplest of terms to describe what this alleged immigration scheme aimed to do, was that immigration officials were misled with falsified visa petitions that claimed potential visa beneficiaries would be functioning as professional soccer coaches and scouts. 

But from what the DOJ alleges, these visa beneficiaries weren’t being allocated to professional sports teams as scouts or assistant coaches – they were instead allegedly working as youth soccer coaches for GPS:

“The petitions falsely stated that the beneficiaries would be working as scouts or assistant coaches for the professional teams when in reality they were employed only as youth soccer coaches by GPS.”

“As part of the conspiracy, Capell and others submitted phony employment contracts between professional teams and the purported beneficiaries.”

“It is also alleged that Capell and co-conspirators created fraudulent coaching licenses for the beneficiaries, which were included as part of the visa application packages.”

Of course, this is where the professional soccer teams – like the Murphy’s Sky Blue FC – come into the fold.

Apparently, in order for GPS to petition for these visa, then they needed to reference professional soccer teams that these visa beneficiaries would be allocated to. 

One of the unidentified co-conspirators in this case allegedly submitted a petition on Sky Blue FC’s behalf to secure seven P-1S visas, which said category of visas are meant for support (like coaches and the ilk) of professional athletes. 

One month after those seven petitions for visa beneficiaries was filed, then the same co-conspirator submitted another petition that on behalf of Sky Blue FC trying to acquire six more P-1S visas. 

The common theme in all this, as alleged by officials, is that these P1S visa recipients were never allocated to Sky Blue FC – but to youth soccer endeavors under GPS’s watch. 

Governor Murphy reportedly admitted that he hardly ever gets involved with the “day to day” efforts of Sky Blue FC, noting that he and his wife only own a “big chunk” of the team and not much else: 

“I don’t have any involvement day to day in running the team, which is good news for everybody.”

There is one alleged email communication where Governor Murphy was asked back in May of 2016 by Sky Blue FC co-owner Steven Temares if it’s, “ok for Dick [presumably Attorney Richard Howe] to have one conversation with the GPS CEO and the Fragomen lawyer to confirm whether the scouting structure works , ” to which Governor Murpky replied, “absolutely”. 

But outside of the aforementioned, there’s nothing yet that implies Governor Murphy or the other co-owners of the soccer team were in on the alleged visa scandal. 

According to the DOJ, former GPS COO Capell has reportedly already agreed, “to plead guilty to conspiracy to commit visa fraud,” but there’s no determined hearing date on when that plea bargain will be introduced and accepted. 

Do you want to join our private family of first responders and supporters?  Get unprecedented access to some of the most powerful stories that the media refuses to show you.  Proceeds get reinvested into having active, retired and wounded officers, their families and supporters tell more of these stories.  Click to check it out.

LET Unity

It seems that controversy has a thing for tailing Governor Murphy, as we reported back in May of 2020 about a sexual harassment lawsuit settlement linked to one of Governor Murphy’s aides. 

Here’s that previous report. 


TRENTON, N.J.- What is it with politicians and sexual assault?

We all remember Bill Clinton and the blue dress. Yes, we know that was consensual. There’s just that little thing about sexual harassment and stuff.

Then more recently we had Joe Biden and Tara Reade.

Now, it’s an aide to Democrat New Jersey Governor Phil Murphy. Murphy’s campaign and New Jersey taxpayers are on the hook for a $1 million legal settlement to a woman who said she was sexually assaulted by Murphy’s aide during his 2017 gubernatorial run. reported that the woman, Katie Brennan, made an agreement to settle the case in lieu of the $1 million settlement.

The man whom she accused, Al Alvarez, will have to enter a “restorative justice” program, and he has agreed to attend an anti-sexual harassment class. Brennan is also required to attend the program as part of the settlement.

As part of the settlement, $600,000 will go to a charity of Brennan’s choice, while her attorneys will realize a $400,000 payday.

The state of New Jersey and Murphy for Governor, Inc. will pay the settlement. reported that neither party admitted any wrongdoing.

Brennan noted that the charity portion of her settlement will go to a non-profit group, Waterfront Project, which will use the donation in order to help low-income survivors of sexual assault.

As part of the restorative justice program, it will also include an “anti-sexual harassment” class for Alvarez, as well as facilitate meetings between Brennand and Alvarez within six months.

“I hope that this can create a model program for other New Jersey survivors,” Brennand stated. “Living in silence did not serve me or any other survivors in this state. Speaking out gave me great strength.”

The New Jersey Law Journal said that in addition to the monetary settlement, victims of discrimination, harassment or retaliation will be allowed to be accompanied by an adviser or support person during an interview by a division investigator.

That will be facilitated by the New Jersey Division of Equal Employment Opportunity/Affirmative Action in the New Jersey Civil Service Commission.

This particular program was one of a number of changes in either state law or policies that Brennan had asked for after she said that the system had “failed her” after she made her complaint.

Brennan will also be permitted by the state to make a presentation about additional proposed reforms to the state attorney general’s Sexual Assault Nurse Examiner Council, a news release said.

Brennan went public with her allegations in October 2017 to a national news outlet, alleging that Alvarez had raped her six months earlier. She further said that Murphy’s administration had blocked her efforts to hold both Alvarez and the governor’s office that hired him accountable.

In response to the settlement, Murphy said:

“It’s a fair and reasonable settlement. We’ve worked collaboratively and constructively with Katie and her team to institute meaningful reforms to support survivors in the workplace.

We look forward to continuing our work on these issues to make New Jersey a leading state for survivor-centric policies as we have been doing now for a long time.”

Brennan who joined Murphy’s campaign as a volunteer said she was raped by Alvarez in her apartment in 2017 after the two had attended a gathering with other members of Murphy’s campaign.  

Brennan went public with her allegations in 2018. That led to a firestorm that resulted in legislative hearings, as well as a critical legislative report which focused on how Brennan’s case was mishandled. said that aside from the specifics of the Brennan complaint, the incident led to conversations in the state capital about non-disclosure agreements in campaigns, the handling of sexual assault complaints within state government, and a “culture of sexual harassment and misogyny in New Jersey politics.”

According to, “20 female campaign staffers, lobbyists, political operatives and lawmakers shared stories of being groped, sexually propositioned, harassed or marginalized while trying to build careers in state and local politics.”

The women said that politics and government seems to serve as a breeding ground for misogyny, where if women want to have a chance for success in the political realm.

Some of the women told stories about being sexually assaulted after work in the past five years. One complained about being drugged at a political convention over ten years ago. Many spoke of being touched inappropriately or having sexual remarks made to them, some as recently as last year, after Brennan’s complaint.

New Jersey, and likely more states than just that seem to serve as a breeding ground for sexual harassment and/or sexual assault and many unfortunately appear to turn a blind eye to it. One political consultant said:

“Despite everything we hear about #MeToo, it has not made one difference in New Jersey. It just hasn’t I hate to be so negative.”

After Brennan went public, Alvarez denied the allegations and was never arrested, with two county prosecutors who reviewed the case declining to prosecute.

Brennan worked on Murphy’s campaign as the head of Latino and Muslim outreach, while Alvarez later served as deputy director of personnel for the Murphy transition team, while he afterward was chief of staff to the New Jersey Schools Development Authority.

When Brennan went public with her allegations against him, Alvarez was forced to resign.

Brennan seemed relieved that the long process was hover, and she said she was “hopeful” that she helped facilitate the reforms she was hoping for. She was also grateful for the assistance she received from her attorneys, advisers, and sexual assault survivor groups, she said.

“From legislation and the release from NDAs, to greater awareness of harassment and assault, we’ve made great progress. Each reform sets us on a path toward justice. Each reform makes it worth the pain,” Brennan said.

Want to make sure you never miss a story from Law Enforcement Today?  With so much “stuff” happening in the world on social media, it’s easy for things to get lost.  

Make sure you click “following” and then click “see first” so you don’t miss a thing!  (See image below.)  Thanks for being a part of the LET family!

Facebook Follow First

Submit a Correction
Related Posts