ELIZABETH, PA- There’s understandable outrage out of Elizabeth, Pennsylvania today. That’s where the police chief was able to steal thousands of bags of heroin from police evidence and will be serving exactly zero days in jail.
The former police chief in Elizabeth Borough, Timothy Butler, will not be serving any jail time after he pleaded guilty to stealing heroin from the police department’s evidence room.
Keep in mind, there are people who have served time, in fact, years for stealing cigarettes from convenience stores.
Yet someone we endowed with trust can do some in-house stealing and practically get away clean.
Timothy Butler was sentenced this past Wednesday to 45 months’ probation and 325 hours of community service.
According to the criminal complaint lodged, evidence envelopes labeled to have originally contained approximately 2,531 bags of heroin were all empty.
Also recovered from the trash can in Butler’s office were 62 bags and 2,700 loose stamp bags, according to the criminal complaint. The items were all examined and found to be emptied of contents.
Take into consideration that in the state of Pennsylvania, possession of a simple gram of heroin can land you in prison for a single year on the very first offense.
That’s just having some heroin on you that can land that amount of time, but if you stole it from a police precinct, do you think you’d be looking at probation? Not to mention the damage that can come from tampering with evidence that could be linked to active cases.
The criminal complaint says that, after being questioned about suspicious activity last year, Butler admitted that he had become addicted to heroin after taking prescription Vicodin for neck and back pain.
Questionable sentencing aside, this is an ongoing problem with people being prescribed opiates to alleviate pain, as consuming any of the branded opioids doctors dole out creates addicts of all kind. But should addiction, no matter how bad, be that much of a mitigating factor that someone serves zero time for blatant thievery?
The court document said that after first making the admission to one of his officers, Butler had met with the township solicitor, mayor and council president at the borough building.
The criminal complaint recounts that:
“Butler was crying at the time, and apologized, stating that he could not believe this was happening to him.”
Butler at one point during the meeting had blamed the doctors for his actions, saying:
“Once they got me off the pills, I had no choice.”
Yet, according to John H. Halpern, M.D., the “no choice” argument is one that he has been debunking for years when addressing the “addiction is a disease” notion.
When describing what makes addiction and the acts associated with addiction a choice, Halpern says:
“…foolish, self-destructive activity is not necessarily a disease.”
Still, whether the drugs made the police chief do it, or it was just simple poor decision making when dealing with a substance abuse problem; what most people are rightfully critical of is that there’s absolutely zero jail time being served.
While the chief did manage to come clean to his peers and higher-ups, owning up to a confessed crime doesn’t mean the crime magically becomes less of a crime.
Here at LET, we bleed blue. But part of that means calling out the bad apples. It’s the second time we’ve had to do it this month. This first was in early November, when we reported on a massive FBI sting that found a group of officers getting paid to protect cartel drug trafficking.
You’ve got to hand it to the FBI when it comes to crafting amazing sting operations.
Throughout the years, those kinds of operations have managed to get a myriad of criminals off the streets; but this time, the guilty parties identified by one of their recent stings may have you surprised.
A trio of South Carolina law enforcement officers got caught with their hand in the cartel-cookie jar, with two of the guilty individuals facing up to twenty years in prison.
Three former Orangeburg, South Carolina law enforcement officers, who were fooled by the FBI into thinking they were taking money from a fake drug-running Mexican cartel, have pleaded guilty to various criminal charges connected to the sting.
Evidence that was gathered by the FBI in putting together the case involved wiretaps, covert videos and an undercover agent posing as a member of a fake Mexican drug-trafficking cartel. According to assistant U.S. Attorney Will Lewis, who had described the crimes to Judge Joe Anderson on Tuesday, stated:
“They were engaged in a conspiracy to protect what they believed were drug traffickers.”
In the FBI’s sting, an agent posing as a member of a purported Mexican cartel who called himself “Jamie” told the officers that the cartel’s trucks would be traveling south through Orangeburg County on Interstate 26 with loads of money from selling drugs and then back again traveling north with loads of drugs, according to evidence in the case.
Per the discussed scheme with the undercover agents, the Orangeburg officers agreed to be paid to “guard” the fake truckloads of cash and drugs during the trucks’ layovers near an interstate exit.
Officers stood watch to keep the fake cartel trucks from harm, according to evidence in the case. This act of “guarding” would be executed while the Orangeburg officers were in full uniform while in their police vehicles.
The three who pleaded guilty this past Tuesday had varying charges associated with their level of participation in the collusion.
One of the guilty, Allan Hunter, 51, was a police officer in the town of Springfield in western Orangeburg County. He pleaded guilty to numerous charges connected with taking bribes to protect the fake cartel’s drug-trafficking operations. Hunter also plead guilty to using his position as a law officer to help undocumented immigrants illegally stay in the United States.
Based upon the charges that he accepted, he cold be facing up to 20 years in prison when it’s all said and done.
The second of the trio in the case is Nathaniel Shazier, 29, who was an Orangeburg County sheriff’s deputy. He plead guilty to conspiracy to guard the fake cartel’s trucks during the undercover sting. Shazier is also looking at a 20-year sentence for his role within the conspiracy.
Lastly, Stanley Timmons, 44, was also Orangeburg County sheriff’s deputy like Shazier. He plead guilty to a lesser charge than his two codefendants as only being part of a conspiracy to guard the fake cartel’s trucks. With the lesser charge that was plead to, Timmons could face only 5 years in prison for his role.
The sting also managed to culminate in the arrest of an additional four officers, but their cases are only pending at this point.
What was interesting to find was that the FBI’s sting operation initially began as an investigation into a fraudulent visa-selling scheme that was being run out of the Orangeburg County sheriff’s department.
Under a special program, immigrants without permission to stay in the United States who are victims of crimes, or who are willing to help law enforcement, can apply for special visas, called U-Visas. Once granted, these special visas allow an immigrant to stay in the United States for four years.
It was believed that deputies within the Orangeburg County sheriff’s department were creating counterfeit incident reports alleging that certain foreigners were victims of crimes. Hunter was involved in the original endeavor to fabricate the fake incident reports, and at some point, he began recruiting other officers to guard the fake cartel trucks, according to an indictment in the case.
Considering that the three officers plead guilty in this case already, it tells of the amount of evidence that the FBI had to have collected in order to secure those pleas. Considering that there’s additional cases pending for other officers involved in this sting, those cases might have similar conclusions to those of the three officers already guilty.
Here’s the full list of names and charges:
Did you know that Law Enforcement Today has a private new home for those who support emergency responders and veterans? It’s called LET Unity, and it’s where we share the untold stories of those patriotic Americans. Every penny gets reinvested into giving these heroes a voice. Check it out today.
Springfield Police Department Chief Lacra Sharod Jenkins: Conspiracy, Visa Fraud, Conspiracy to Possess with Intent to Distribute Controlled Substances, and Possession of a Firearm in Furtherance of a Drug Trafficking Crime;
Springfield Police Department Officer Allan Hunter, Jr.: Conspiracy, Visa Fraud, Conspiracy to Possess with Intent to Distribute Controlled Substances, and Possession of a Firearm in Furtherance of a Drug Trafficking Crime;
Orangeburg County Sheriff’s Office Deputy Carolyn Colter Franklin: Conspiracy, Visa Fraud, Conspiracy to Possess with Intent to Distribute Controlled Substances, and Possession of a Firearm in Furtherance of a Drug Trafficking Crime;
Orangeburg County Sheriff’s Office Deputy Nathaniel Miller Shazier, III: Conspiracy, Conspiracy to Possess with Intent to Distribute Controlled Substances, and Possession of a Firearm in Furtherance of a Drug Trafficking Crime
Orangeburg County Sheriff’s Office Deputy Stanley Lavalle Timmons: Conspiracy, Conspiracy to Possess with Intent to Distribute Controlled Substances, and Possession of a Firearm in Furtherance of a Drug Trafficking Crime;
Orangeburg County Sheriff’s Office Reserve Deputy James Albert Tucker: Conspiracy, Conspiracy to Possess with Intent to Distribute Controlled Substances, and Possession of a Firearm in Furtherance of a Drug Trafficking Crime;
Orangeburg County Sheriff’s Office Deputy Willie Paul David Rogers: Conspiracy and Visa Fraud;
Saurabhkumar B. Patel, of Orangeburg, South Carolina: Conspiracy; and
Tarang Patel, of Newport, Kentucky: Conspiracy and Visa Fraud.
“With this Indictment, we honor the hard work and dedication of the very fine officers across South Carolina who put on the police uniform every day and risk their lives to protect the rest of us,” said U.S. Attorney Lydon.
Lyndon said it’s crucial to get rid of the bad apples.
“If these allegations are proved, these defendants do not deserve to wear the badge and should not be allowed to bring disrepute on the overwhelming majority of men and women in blue who serve South Carolina with integrity. We will not tolerate the hypocrisy of those who would pretend to enforce the law, while violating it themselves as they seek to line their own pockets. We call that public corruption, and we will always call it out.”