Detroit, MI – The Public Interest Legal Foundation (PILF) filed a lawsuit in federal court in January against the city of Detroit for allegedly failing to maintain their voter rolls, including leaving more than 2,500 deceased Americans, aged 85 and older, on the books.
Detroit currently has more people registered to vote than are actually eligible.
It is easy to surmise that this is not a mere oversight, but either fraud or gross negligence.
But Michigan’s Democrat Party chairwoman, Christy Jenson, says there is no evidence of voter fraud in Detroit, and if you accuse the city of registering dead people to vote you are racist.
According to the lawsuit, the City of Detroit’s “voter rolls contain thousands of ineligible deceased registrants, some who have been dead for extraordinary amounts of time.”
The lawsuit claims that the city does not have a reasonable list maintenance program to detect and remove deceased registrants from the rolls.
The complaint says that 2,503 dead registrants appear on the city’s voter rolls while another 4,788 voters appear more than once. Additionally, the lawsuit says that Detroit has 511,768 registered voters in a city with only 479,267 eligible adults.
“Based on this data, Detroit has more registered voters than adult citizens of voting age,” states the lawsuit.
In response, Jenson said the lawsuit’s allegations that dead people are registered to vote in Detroit are a “direct attack on people of color” and that there is no evidence of voter fraud:
“This lawsuit is about making a click bait headline,” said Jenson, “to make voters have less confidence in what is happening in their communities, their clerk’s office. And it is really a direct attack on people of color.”
Detroit Clerk Janice Winfrey calls the suit is a “witch hunt designed to disenfranchise the voters.”
Michigan Republican Party Chairwoman Laura Cox said Winfrey, who is responsible for managing the voter rolls, has a “record of failure.”
“When thousands of dead people are registered to vote and there are more people registered than are eligible to vote in the city of Detroit either someone is trying to commit fraud or there is gross incompetence within the Detroit city clerk’s office,” Cox said in a statement.
“Either way Janice Winfrey has shown she is unable to do her job as Detroit City Clerk. It’s time for Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson to replace her partisan friend on the Election Modernization Advisory Committee with someone who knows how to run a modern election operation.”
Breitbart reports that after obtaining voter data from the state of Michigan earlier this year, PILF researchers said they discovered that a number of registered voters had either “impossibly old” or “disqualifying young” dates of births.
In one case, for example, PILF researchers said they found that a registered voter stated they had been born in the year 1823.
For those who don’t want to do that math, they would be 196-years-old.
“The City of Detroit is failing to perform some of the most basic functions owed to its citizenry,” PILF President and General Counsel J. Christian Adams said.
“The city government’s nonchalant attitude toward addressing evidence of dead and duplicate registrations exposes yet another vulnerability in our voting systems as our nation works to improve election security before November 2020.
Making a federal case out of this was necessary, and I hope we can achieve a resolution before the polls open.”
Perhaps we should stop using the line, “You can’t make this stuff up” because some are seeing that as a challenge.
Joe Schoffstall of the Washington Free Beacon reported that liberal groups and high-powered New York attorneys swooped into Detroit to help the city fight a lawsuit over these irregularities.
The League of Women Voters of Michigan and its Detroit chapter filed a motion to intervene on behalf of Winfrey and Director of Elections George Azzouz.
The Brennan Center for Justice, a progressive policy institute at New York University School of Law, will help the League fight PILF’s lawsuit.
Myrna Pérez, the center’s director of voting rights and elections programs, and Eliza Sweren-Becker, counsel in the center’s Democracy Program, signed on to the motion. New York-based attorneys from the Paul Weiss law firm, where former Obama attorney general Loretta Lynch is a partner, also joined the motion.
The liberal groups and attorneys are converging on Detroit as part of a broader campaign against alleged efforts to “purge” individuals from voter rolls.
Democrats have built a massive network of nonprofit groups, funded by George Soros and other liberal donors, to oppose Republican-backed voting initiatives such as voter identification laws. Michigan is a significant target for such efforts given its “swing state” status; Trump won the state by just 10,000 votes in the 2016 election.
“The national 2020 elections will be held in less than nine months,” the League states in its February motion. “If a resolution of this matter—whether by court order or through a negotiated settlement—results in an aggressive purge and a heightened standard for voter list maintenance beyond reasonableness, the League may not have significant time to remedy the issue.”
Logan Churchwell, communications director for PILF, said the groups still must convince the court they belong in the room.
“This is yet more evidence of the left’s deep investments to preserve faulty voter registration records and the questionable procedures at the root of the problem,” Churchwell said.
The League of Women Voters of Michigan did not respond to a request for comment. Robert Atkins, the top attorney from Paul Weiss listed on the motion, also did not respond.
Many of the attorneys working with the League have donated to Democratic presidential and Senate candidates this cycle. Atkins, co-chair of Paul Weiss’s litigation department, has provided contributions ranging from $250 to $3,000 to the presidential campaigns of Joe Biden, Pete Buttigieg, Kamala Harris, and Cory Booker.
Atkins also donated to the Senate campaigns of Cal Cunningham, running in North Carolina, and Theresa Greenfield, running in Iowa. The IA/NC Senate 2020 committee, a joint fundraising venture between Cunningham and Greenfield, is bankrolled by dozens of attorneys at the firm, including Atkins and Loretta Lynch.
The committee has so far pushed $100,000 to each of the candidates. On Dec. 16, it disbursed $1,100 to Paul Weiss for catering and room rental.
Another attorney listed on the League’s motion, William Michael, has also given thousands to Democratic presidential candidates like Biden and and former hopeful, Amy Klobuchar.
Employees at Paul Weiss provided more than $1 million to Democrats and $180,000 to Republicans so far this cycle, according to the Center for Responsive Politics.
Democrats began their attempts to chip away at Republican voting initiatives prior to the 2016 election. After Trump’s victory, however, they mobilized to build a more robust infrastructure.
Marc Elias, a top Democratic lawyer at the Washington, D.C., office of the Perkins Coie law firm, led efforts to combat voter identification laws during the 2016 cycle.
Elias, who was Hillary Clinton’s top campaign lawyer at the time, brought lawsuits forward in several states, including Virginia, Ohio, Wisconsin, and North Carolina. The campaign was heavily funded by George Soros, who expressed a goal of expanding the electorate by 10 million voters.
Following the 2016 election, Elias joined the board of Priorities USA to lead its nonprofit arm’s efforts against state voting laws. Priorities USA additionally absorbed Every Citizen Counts, a nonprofit created by Clinton allies that focused on mobilizing Latino and African-American voters. The group began to zero in on voting issues.
Several organizations carrying the same mission sprang up around that time.
Let America Vote, a nonprofit established by former Democratic Missouri secretary of state Jason Kander, was one. It works with other liberal outfits and contains dozens of high-level operatives on its advisory board, including Elias, Stacey Abrams, and Guy Cecil, chairman of Priorities USA.
Last month out of Chicago, we reported about how alarms have been raised over the years about government officials trying to “dumb down” the voter registration process.
From using so-called “motor voter” initiatives where people could register when renewing their license and/or registration to automatic voter registration programs conducted at the same times, the system is rife for abuse.
In Illinois, it is being reported that a technical error has resulted in more than 500 non-U.S. citizens being registered to vote in the state, sparking criticism of the state’s automatic voter registration system.
State lawmakers and election authorities were understandably angry over the news, Republicans in particular.
Republican Representative Rodney Davis, along with other Republicans in the state legislature are working to address the “integrity of Illinois elections,” according to a tweet by the Illinois State House GOP.
Matt Dietrich of the Illinois State Board of Elections said:
“We view it as a significant problem.”
Thank you Captain Obvious.
Dietrich said that individuals should not have been able to register as voters after they checked the “non-citizenship” box.
“The way that that’s supposed to work and the reason that box is there is that if someone checks that, they are instantly excluded from the automatic voter registration system.”
Apparently, not so much.
LET has a private home for those who support emergency responders and veterans called LET Unity. We reinvest the proceeds into sharing untold stories of those patriotic Americans. Click to check it out.
There has been a call among state lawmakers to have the auto-registration system suspended. They have further demanded a “zero tolerance policy” for voter fraud, as well as an investigation into the Secretary of State’s office.
In a letter, Secretary of State Jesse White’s office said that a “programming error” in a signature pad at driver services facilities let to hundreds of non-U.S. citizens accidentally being registered as voters.
According to the Secretary of State’s Office, the problem had been fixed last Tuesday, however lawmakers are only now raising questions about the incident.
The “Automatic Voter Registration” bill was signed by former governor Bruce Rauner in 2017. The law requires eligible Illinois citizens to be automatically registered to vote when they apply for or renew a driver’s license or ID, unless they opt out. Knowing Illinois, they are probably also automatically registered as Democrats.
“For whatever reason that technological programming error did not properly remove the individuals,” the letter said. “The individuals who are applying for driver’s licenses were inadvertently pooled into the automatic voter registration.”
You see, this is the problem with trying to idiot-proof things such as voter registrations.
While Democrats in Congress worry about voter fraud caused by invisible “Russian bots”, the real fraud is caused by programs such as automating registrations and electronic game playing with voting machines.
According to a spokesman for the Secretary of State’s Office, non-citizens who were registered to vote are here legally. They are not undocumented immigrants, and they did not lie on their forms; it was the state error that signed them up to vote.
I mean, that would “never” happen.
“We discovered an error, and we fixed it. And then we notified the State Board of Elections and the local election authorities and the individuals that were impacted,” they said in the statement.
While the scale of the problem is relatively small, it does highlight the possible glitches that can happen when you dumb down the process. It has been reported that of the 574 people who could have been registered, only 16 actually cast ballots.
The State Board of Elections said three of the non-citizen ballots were cast in Chicago. They are working with local election authorities to make sure anyone who was mistakenly registered is taken off the rolls.
“Even though, in the grand scheme of our election registration numbers and the voting numbers, the figures that we’re looking at are very small,” said Dietrich. “This issue is significant in terms of we want to make sure there is complete integrity with our automatic voter registration system.”
Republicans have long been concerned over potential voter fraud with the system and says that the error undermines the integrity of state elections.
“I don’t have a lot of confidence in the Secretary of State’s Office right now,” said Illinois State Representative Tim Butler (R-Springfield).
He is demanding a House investigation into the secretary of state’s office.
“He may or may not have known about this, I have no idea. But he needs to be held responsible for it; it’s his operation that allowed this to happen,” Butler said.
In a written statement, the state Republican chairman said that people needed to be held accountable:
“It simply is inexcusable that non-citizens voted in Illinois and potentially affected the outcome of elections across the state. Those in the Secretary of State’s Office who allowed this to happen should be terminated from their employment with the State.”
In response to the glitch, the Public Interest Legal Foundation, an election integrity firm, has requested records from the State Board of Elections. The group complains that Democratic politicians are pushing automatic voter registration at the expense of election integrity.
The same type of program that was implemented in Illinois has also been implemented in 18 other states, plus the District of Columbia. The group feels that the issues highlighted in Illinois make it possible that non-citizens in other states are also making their way on to voter lists nationwide.
“States have no business experimenting with automatic voter registration until they can zero out the risk of ineligible noncitizens passing through traditional Motor Voter,” said Logan Churchwell.
He’s the communications director at PILF.
“This is not a new problem for Illinois. That state’s Motor Voter system made national news in 2017, well before policymakers foolishly installed automatic voter registration,” Churchwell said.
“States like Virginia, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Michigan, California, Georgia, Florida and more have demonstrated how foreign nationals can and do enter voter registries through the Motor Voter process, regardless of automation.”
“The Foundation fully expects there are mor eforeign nationals still registered to vote in Illinois—and some of them voted in 2018,” he said. “We just don’t know who they are yet since they haven’t felt the need to self-report—but their time will come.”
Perhaps Adam Schiff and the other headhunters in the Congress would be better served by looking for collusion and voter fraud where it really exists—in the Motor Voter programs nationwide.
Want to make sure you never miss a story from Law Enforcement Today? With so much “stuff” happening in the world on social media, it’s easy for things to get lost.