‘This is what evil looks like’: Sheriff’s deputy on life support, suspect shot in separate confrontation with homeowner


AVONDALE, AZ – Authorities say that a 30-year-old man critically injured a Maricopa County Sheriff’s deputy while being processed at a sheriff’s substation earlier in October, with the unnamed deputy currently on life support as a result of the attack.

The suspect was reportedly later taken into custody after being shot by a homeowner in Tonapah in a separate incident.

According to officials, 30-year-old Clinton Robert Hurley was being processed by a MCSO deputy outside of the District 2 substation near Van Buren and Dysart on October 9th for various felony charges when authorities say Hurley injured the deputy.

During a press conference regarding the incident, Sheriff Paul Penzone stated that the suspect then took off in the deputy’s vehicle, crashing through a fence and fleeing the area, adding the following about the suspect:

“This is the perfect example of what evil looks like. Somebody who doesn’t deserve to live in a free society assaulted a good young man who is willing to protect you and your family.”

The specific nature of the deputy’s sustained injuries were not shared by officials.

A manhunt was initiated regarding the suspect, with deputies reportedly later responding to a residence at approximately 6:30 p.m. near 373rd Avenue and Buckeye Road in Tonapah about a shooting incident.

A homeowner at the residence had apparently exchanged gunfire with Hurley, with authorities later finding the suspect nearby and transporting him to an area hospital.

Sheriff Penzone noted that the homeowner that shot Hurley was familiar with the suspect, saying that the two had a history of conflict, but did not afford any detail beyond that mentioning.

While Sheriff Penzone did not identify the injured deputy by name, he did describe him as a “young man” and added that he’d been with the sheriff’s office for three years. In light of the incident, the sheriff said that he’s praying for a miracle regarding the deputy and urged locals to be supportive of law enforcement:

“Are you going to stand with us and get bad people off the street? Or are you going to scrutinize good men and women who have the conviction, the courage and the willingness to do a difficult job in the face of scrutiny?”

The suspect accused of injuring the deputy had been released from prison this past December after being convicted of attempted molestation of a child back in 2014.

Hurley is currently in critical condition at the hospital following the shooting, according to reports.

This is an ongoing investigation.

Please follow Law Enforcement Today as we continue to gather further insight into this developing case.

Do you want to join our private family of first responders and supporters?  Get unprecedented access to some of the most powerful stories that the media refuses to show you.  Proceeds get reinvested into having active, retired and wounded officers, their families and supporters tell more of these stories.  Click to check it out.

LET Unity

In an update to a previous report we at Law Enforcement Today shared in October, the deceased suspect involved in the Amtrak train shooting incident in Tucson that resulted in a DEA agent being fatally shot has been identified as 26-year-old Darrion Taylor.

In our previous report, it was unclear whether the suspect had taken their own life or not while holed up inside of a restroom in one of the train’s cabin’s after firing at law enforcement officers. 

However, officials say that Taylor had been shot several times in the torso and limbs and the gunshot wound don’t appear to be self-inflicted. 

The DEA agent killed during the incident was also identified as Michael Garbo, cited as being a longtime DEA group supervisor. Having served as a Nashville Police officer before joining the DEA in 2005, his career saw him pursuing drug traffickers in Arizona, Afghanistan and then back to Arizona by 2011.

As for the suspect who was taken into custody following shooting, who was reportedly not involved in the gunfire between law enforcement and Taylor, he was identified as Devonte Okeith Mathis.

Reports indicate Mathis was taken into custody under charges of possession with the intent to distribute less than 50 kilograms of a mixture or substance containing marijuana.

Here’s our previous report from earlier in October. 


Under attack: Shooting on Amtrak train leaves DEA agent and suspect dead, two more officers wounded

(Originally published October 5th, 2021)

TUCSON, AZ – A shooting incident that happened aboard an Amtrak train in Tucson earlier in October resulted in a DEA agent being killed. Authorities say that the suspect involved in the shooting was also fatally shot during the incident.

According to Tucson Police Chief Chris Magnus, the incident started at approximately 8:00 a.m. on October 4th while DEA agents and Tucson Police officers boarded the train car to conduct a routine inspection for any contraband like illegal drugs, weapons, and the sort.

Chief Magnus stressed that such inspections are a standard practice at all transit hubs.

While officers were in the middle of detaining a man on the upper-level of the double-decker train car, a second man reportedly produced a firearm and started shooting at officers.

Authorities say that the suspect exchanged several rounds of gunfire with officers before barricading himself in a bathroom on the cabin’s lower level.

Officials say that the suspect was later found dead inside of the bathroom he’d barricaded himself in. It’s unclear as of this writing how the alleged gunman died while barricaded.

As for the other suspect that police were in the process of detaining before the gunfire erupted, he has since been arrested. It’s unclear what charges the individual in custody is facing and what relationship he had with the suspect who opened fire on authorities.

During the incident, one DEA agent was killed, while another agent and a Tucson Police officer were injured. Reports indicate that the wounded DEA agent is in critical condition. As for the Tucson Police officer, officials say the officer is in stable condition.

Amtrak spokesman Jason Abrams stated that none of the 137 passengers and 11 crew members were harmed during the gunfire.

Chief Magnus noted that the shooting was “horrific” but that he was proud of how bravely agents and officers responded:

“It’s very horrific and we’re all just coming to terms with just how terrible a loss this is. But I also want to reflect on the really heroic actions of the officers at the scene. They literally ran towards the danger, into the car, where there was an active shooting situation going on.”

The identity of the deceased agent and the others injured have not been released by officials, nor have the names of any of the suspects been released either.

This is an ongoing investigation.

Please follow Law Enforcement Today as we continue to gather further insight into this developing case.

Do you want to join our private family of first responders and supporters?  Get unprecedented access to some of the most powerful stories that the media refuses to show you.  Proceeds get reinvested into having active, retired and wounded officers, their families and supporters tell more of these stories.  Click to check it out.

LET Unity

Arizona man charged with murdering four people found dead in a Wisconsin cornfield

(Originally published September 23rd, 2021)

ST PAUL, MN – A 38-year-old man from Scottsdale, Arizona, has been charged in connection with four murders that occurred in St. Paul, Minnesota, earlier in September. Authorities say that the bodies of all four victims were found in an abandoned SUV in a Wisconsin cornfield.

Very little has been revealed by authorities about what exactly led to the murders of 30-year-old Nitosha Flug-Presley, 35-year-old Loyace Foreman III, 26-year-old Matthew Pettus, and 30-year-old Jasmine Sturm – but a man from Arizona, identified as 38-year-old Antoine Suggs has been arrested in connection with the killings.

According to the criminal complaint against Suggs, witnesses alleged that victim Flug-Presley and a man they believed to be Suggs were seen together at the White Squirrel bar in St. Paul on the evening of September 11th transitioning to the morning of September 12th.

Roughly a block away from the White Squirrel bar is Shamrocks Grill and Pub, where victims Foreman, Pettus, and Sturm were.

They headed to the White Squirrel bar to meet up with Flug-Presley at approximately 1:00 a.m. on September 12th.

One witness later said they’d seen three of the known victims, Flug-Presley, Sturm and Pettus, getting into the back of an SUV at approximately 2:00 a.m. within an unknown man. Authorities say that no one had any contact with the victims at that point onward.

Officials believe that Suggs may have killed the four victims on West Seventh Street in St. Paul between 3:30 a.m. and 3:48 a.m.

Cellphone records note that Suggs called his father, Darren Osborne, approximately one hour after the alleged murders. Three hours after the call to his father, a security video near St. Paul showed a Mercedes-Benz SUV being closely followed by a Nissan Rogue, which was subsequently identified as Suggs’ mother’s car.

The Mercedes-Benz and Nissan were later spotted at a gas station in St. Paul more than two hours later after the aforementioned surveillance footage.

Surveillance video reportedly shows Flug-Presley “slumped over” in the front passenger seat of the SUV, which is how she was discovered in the SUV near Sheridan Township, Wisconsin, according to police.

Because Suggs was not wearing a mask, police were able to identify him on security footage from the gas station.

The same two vehicles were also reportedly spotted driving up together at a gas station 10 miles from where the bodies were discovered in Wisconsin, police say.

In obtained security footage, Osborne is reportedly seen walking inside a shop to purchase some items. Later, near where the Mercedes-Benz was parked, investigators discovered apparent blood traces on the ground.

When police later located the vehicle and bodies of the four victims, they noted that there were six shell casings inside of the vehicle and also Sugg’s Arizona ID that was covered in blood.

When police first caught up with Osbourne, who was the first to be arrested in connection with the case, he told investigators that his son abruptly showed up 5:00 a.m. on September 12th with his mother in tow and urged his parents to “get along with each other” and asked his parents to please watch after his children.

Suggs’ mother then left, leaving the murder suspect and his father Osborne to themselves. Osborne told police that his son asked him to follow him in his mother’s car – later revealing to Osbourne that he “had snapped and shot a couple people.”

Osborne reportedly admitted to police that he went with his son to drop off the SUV containing the victims’ bodies in Wisconsin, noting that he did not know the victims personally.

Osborne has since been charged with four counts of hiding a corpse with intent to conceal a crime and is being held in the Ramsey County Jail.

Suggs reportedly turned himself into authorities in Arizona on September 17th and has since been charged with four counts of second-degree murder. He’s currently awaiting extradition back to Minnesota.

If convicted, Suggs could face up to 160 years in prison.


 Want to make sure you never miss a story from Law Enforcement Today?  With so much “stuff” happening in the world on social media, it’s easy for things to get lost.  

Make sure you click “following” and then click “see first” so you don’t miss a thing!  (See image below.)  Thanks for being a part of the LET family!
Facebook Follow First
Related Posts