What exactly is a hate crime? Well, most people who are familiar with the law would simply say that a crime committed against someone based upon their race, or religion, or even orientation.

So would a white woman being attacked while having “white mother***ers” screamed at them constitute one?

From a federal perspective, yes, as per federal law a hate crime is committed the basis of another crime is influenced by a person’s protected characteristics of race, religion, ethnicity, nationality, gender, sexual orientation, gender identity, and disability.

However, no news sites are calling this what it is: a hate crime.

A model, Prendinellys Garcia, 47, and an actress, Jennifer Agostini, 43,  were both brutally assaulted by what can be best described as a racist pack of scoundrels during a Midtown bar brawl, according to a new lawsuit seeking to force the venue to hang on to surveillance footage of the throw-down.

This doesn’t seem like some Jussie Smollett fiasco of crying wolf either, as the disturbing photographs of the injuries sustained show evidence of a merciless beating.

Did you know that Law Enforcement Today has a private new home for those who support emergency responders and veterans?  It’s called LET Unity, and it’s where we share the untold stories of those patriotic Americans.  Every penny gets reinvested into giving these heroes a voice.  Check it out today.

Jennifer Agostini and Prendinellys Garcia went out for a night of fun in celebration of their friend’s birthday party at Midtown lounge Sky Room before leaving around 3:00 a.m. this past Sunday, their Manhattan Supreme Court lawsuit says.

Yet, on their way out of the West 40th Street club, they got jumped and beaten to the ground by a group of 10 to 15 people who were composed of mostly black women that were yelling “white mother***ers,” “dirty white b****es” and “f**k those white b****es and their money,” according to court documents.

Agostini, who recently spoke to the New York Post about the incident, detailed the following:

“It was just this stampede as we were leaving. We just got rushed and assaulted by, I can’t tell you by how many people. I’m a lead character on the series in March, and I have to now go to see numerous plastic surgeons, and I also have to go back to the concussion center to MRI my head.”

According to Agostini, she’s scheduled to begin filming on a upcoming series called “Brooklyn Ties” this spring.

The photos showcasing the aftermath of the brutal attack show Agostini’s bruised and swollen face, with matted hair drenched in her own blood.

Garcia’s husband, Cal Stuart, mentioned the devastation the horrific act has caused them since their careers have an element of outwardly beauty to them:

“These are beautiful women and their faces are distorted.

Agostini and the others, who are asking a judge to have the bar keep surveillance video and other records of the incident, say they don’t know exactly why the brawl erupted.

According to the victims, the incident touched off when one of their friends tried to go back into the bar for a forgotten credit card after their party had left, according to court papers. It was alleged that the bouncer then pushed the woman, and they got into a verbal spat when Stuart told him to lay off, and according to Stuart:

“All of a sudden, 10 to 15 people jumped us.”

While they never filed a police report initially, it remains to be seen whether they will or won’t.

Agostini recounted the horrendous beating that ensued:

“I was pushed onto the ground and eight individuals jumped on top of me and brutally assaulted me. I have five stitches in my head. My whole eye is closed. I am going to have numerous scars on my face.”

Garcia added that:

“I have a black eye. I have been having a lot of headaches. My whole entire body hurts. They were punching and kicking me on my body.”

The suit named Sky Room’s parent company, The Sky Bar Times Square Inc., and two other companies in the suit. At this time Sky Room did not immediately offer any comments related to the brawl outside their establishment.

It’s no surprise that the media wouldn’t call this a hate crime, considering that 1 out of 45 physical altercations that involve a white perpetrator and a black victim are treated as hate crimes; whereas when you have a black perpetrator and a white victim, only 1 out of 1254 incidents are treated as hate crimes. I’m no statistician, but something seems off there.

Earlier this year… we posted the question of whether we be prosecuting “hate crimes” or just the crimes themselves.

Ever since Jussie Smollet, everyone is talking about “hate crimes” again.

Of course they’re not referring to attacks on Trump supporters as being hate crimes.  After all, Trump’s haters are responsible for being attacked because they’re wearing MAGA hats, right?

Attack on off duty cop wearing MAGA hat

MAGA hats have been the source of hatred from those Anti-Trumpers who believe it is symbolic of hate.

 

Hate crime.  It’s perhaps one of the larger hypocrisies here in America.  And it’s time we eliminate the laws surrounding them … because they are dividing our country.

Let me break it down for you.

The term “hate crime” is largely agreed upon as being “a crime motivated by racial, sexual, or other prejudice, typically one involving violence.”  And in the United States, hate crime laws are those that further punish crimes based on the thought behind them.

If someone rapes a woman, he is charged with sexual assault.

But if someone rapes a gay man, he is charged with sexual assault AND a hate crime.

In doing so, we have essentially said that gay men are a protected class and women are not.  Is that not sexist at its very core?  Is the life of a gay man more valuable than the life of a woman?  Of course not. The two lives are equal.  So why create laws that say one life is more important than another?

If a Muslim man beats a Christian man, he’s charged with assault.

If a Christian man beats a Muslim man, he’s charged with assault AND a hate crime.

Is that not a conflict of the separation of church and state?  Are we not saying we value one faith more than another?  That one is more worthy of being protected than another?

Murder, for example, is rooted in hate.  Does the reason WHY you hate someone make it more or less of a crime?  Let’s say a woman murders someone because he sexually assaulted her child … isn’t that murder committed with hate?  If we can agree on that premise, then isn’t it a hate crime?

Designating something as a “hate crime” is a totalitarian move that should be ruled a violation of freedom of thought and speech. It’s based on the idea that when it comes to particular groups, certain rights may be suspended as liberals see fit.  In doing so, you give an advantage to one group over another at the EXPENSE of other people based entirely on ethnicity, race, religion, sexuality, or other factors.

prosecuting hate crimes

We need to punish the crime, not the thought.  Doesn’t the federal Constitution guarantee “equal protection under the law?”

If we are going to follow the rule of law, then we need to stop discriminating against some Americans to create an entitled mentality and special rights and privileges for other Americans.

But of course suggesting we apply common sense and Constitutional guidance to our legal system makes you a racist, sexist, Islamaphobic, homophobic bigot.

And back to attacks on Trump supporters for a second. If we’re going to prosecute crimes based on “thoughts” and “feelings”, shouldn’t we be labeling attacks on Trump supporters as “hate crimes”?

This detective thinks so.

I’ve been a detective for more than 20 years. My father was a detective.  His father was a detective.

I never gave a damn about politics.  My father and grandfather both did.  They were both Kennedy Democrats.

President Trump, Thin blue line, blue lives matter

Interestingly, they both voted for Trump.  Truthfully, I didn’t vote.  My grandfather, before he passed last year, put it pretty simply: 

“Look deeper,” he told me. 

“You’re a detective.  Put it all together.  There’s a reason they hate Trump.  And they’ll do anything to stop him.  He’s not a cop – but he’s still one of US.”

Since my grandfather passed last year, I’ve investigated no fewer than 5 “hate crimes”.  And guess what?  They all turned out to be false.

What did they have in common?  They were all unfounded accusations made to look Trump supporters look like racists, homophobes or sexists.  My grandfather told me to look deeper.  I didn’t.  Until this Jussie Smollett story.  And now my eyes are opened.

In one of my investigations, there were “join the KKK” fliers passed around a condo community – about 100 of them.  They looked completely legit.  Except they were, well, childish.  Residents were up in arms. 

It took a week to conclude the investigation. A 15-year-old minority was captured on two separate cameras distributing the fliers.  He admitted he had done it to “get peoples’ heads right about racism in America”.

Kavanaugh

Judge Brett Kavanaugh. (U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit)

 

Two more investigations – both post-Kavanaugh. Both “rape” allegations.  Both with significant social media noise surrounding them.  Both tied to the “me too” movement.

Both turned out to be false.  One woman was upset because the man had publicly humiliated her by dumping her in a restaurant.  The other openly admitted – after being caught in a flat out lie – that she thought men needed to start to suffer for what the “toxicity of men” has been doing to a generation of boys.

Huh?

Two more cases.  One – an attack against a young black man.  His mother called us after he came home bloody and bruised. He told us a bunch of young white boys from a local Christian school attacked him and called him racial slurs.

drug trafficking father

 

Except it only took us two days, three witness statements and a closed circuit video from a corner store to determine he had his ass handed to him for stiffing the guys he had been buying drugs from.

A young gay man getting notes in his locker saying he’d be “skinned” and “hung” for liking boys.

A day later, he broke down in hysterics when we pressed him for details and he admitted that he just wanted attention and that he had written the notes himself.

“Look deeper” my grandfather told me.

This Smollett story really chapped my ass. 

 

You know why?  Because I have a lot of black friends and a lot of gay friends. Several are on the department with me. And I’d damn near kill to protect them. I was enraged when I heard what happened to him.  This is unacceptable in a society where we have fought for years to overcome discrimination.

Except… it didn’t happen.

But the media rallied around him right away, declaring it did.

Liz Warren called the entire criminal justice system racist ‘from front to back.’ (Wikipedia Commons)

 

Elizabeth Warren, who is running for President, rushed to his defense.

Bernie Sanders, also in the running, called it “a horrific instance of the surging hostility toward minorities around the country.”

Collusion? Complaint Says Sanders Violated Federal Election Laws By Hiring Non-American Campaign Advisers

Sens. Cory Booker and Kamala Harris both compared the alleged attack to a “modern-day lynching,” while House Majority Speaker Nancy Pelosi, ex-Vice President Joe Biden and other Dems jumped, fanning racial and LGBTQ divisions and slamming Trump supporters.

The Hollywood elite blamed it on “Trump’s rhetoric.”

Now evidence shows it was all B.S., but you don’t see anyone charging SMOLLETT with a hate crime.  Or anything, for that matter

Look deeper.

False accusations are out of control.

It was done to Brett Kavanaugh, with Democrats alleging, and the media embracing, his female accusers’ outlandish stories of alleged sexual assault from decades ago without corroborating evidence.

Those allegations were later rebuked or debunked.

Look deeper.

Let’s not forget the left’s recent ambush against the Covington High School boys.

The students were quick to be painted as “racists” simply because they’re white, straight and male who committed the ultimate sin — smiling while wearing MAGA hats — on a school trip to DC.

Read: Operation Throat Punch Is the Greatest Trolling of Sex Traffickers by Combat Veterans Ever 

The teenagers were bullied and defamed across the mainstream media.  That was until evidence emerged proving they did nothing wrong.  Now suit is being filed against many of those who defamed the boys, including a lawsuit against the Washington Post for $250 million.

Look deeper.

Now to Drake University, where a former student plead guilty last month to making false reports to police in connection with racist notes found in November on the campus.

19-year-old Kissie Ram pleaded guilty to a simple misdemeanor.  She faced up to a year in jail but was given a deferred judgement that placed her on a 12-month probation.

This after she filed a report that a racist note was found on Campus on November 28.  In total, five notes were found.  At least four of them were considered hoaxes and tied back to Ram. She admitted to writing one of them and reported receiving one of them as well. 

AKA – it was all a bunch of crap.

Look deeper.

In Glastonbury, Connecticut, a man was charged in January after police say he spray painted “KKK” on the wall of an apartment complex elevator and then called police to report the crime.

Alec Kasson, 29, was charged with third-degree intimidation due to bias, second-degree false reporting an incident and several other charges for the vandalism in The Soap Factory Apartments where he lived, police said.

When interviewed by officers, Kasson admitted to writing “KKK,” police said.

The vandalism came amid several complaints of swastikas being drawn around the same apartment complex in the weeks before Kasson’s alleged vandalism, police said.

Look deeper.

I never cared about politics.  Like I said, I didn’t vote in the last presidential election.

But you bet your ass I will in the next one.

Because this crap has to stop.  And it’s pretty clear who the real sexists, racists, and homophobes are in society.

Next time, I’m voting for the orange guy.  Because my grandfather put it best:

“They’ll do anything to stop him.  He’s not a cop – but he’s still one of US.”

Tell us what you think below.


Want to make sure you never miss a story from Law Enforcement Today?  With so much “stuff” happening in the world on social media, it’s easy for things to get lost.

Make sure you click “following” and then click “see first” so you don’t miss a thing!  (See image below.)  Thanks for being a part of the LET family!

Facebook Follow First